Selling a two-, three- or four-family home in Yonkers or the Bronx is two sales in one: you are selling a place to live and an income stream at the same time. In October 2026, ten two- to four-family homes closed in Yonkers at a median of $874,500 after a median of 42 days on the market, according to OneKey MLS closed sales I compiled for my October 2026 market report. That was the highest median of any property type in the city that month. The sellers who get the best result are the ones whose rent roll, leases and paperwork are ready before the first showing.
Here is how buyers look at a multi-family home on either side of the city line, and what you can do now to protect your price.
Two buyer pools, one listing
Every multi-family listing reaches two kinds of buyers at once.
Owner-occupant buyers plan to live in one unit and rent the others. They care about the apartment they will live in, the condition of the building and whether the rent will help carry the mortgage.
Investors buy the income. They want the rent roll, the leases, the expense history and a clear picture of what the building costs to own.
A pricing strategy that works for both pools gives you the most leverage. When a listing speaks to only one, it gives up buyers before it starts.
How a multi-family home is valued
Buyers, their lenders and appraisers use two methods side by side.
Comparable sales. Recent closed sales of similar two- to four-family homes nearby, matched on unit count and mix, size, lot, parking, condition and location. In both Yonkers and the Bronx, the same building can trade very differently a few blocks apart.
The income approach. Gross annual rents, minus an allowance for vacancy, minus operating expenses such as property taxes, insurance, water and sewer, repairs and any utilities the owner pays. What is left is net operating income (NOI). Investors compare the NOI with the price to judge their return. Mortgage payments are not part of this number.
The price that sells is the one that holds up under both. I walk through each step with an example in my guide to how to value a two-family home in Yonkers.
Yonkers and the Bronx: what is different
| Yonkers | The Bronx | |
|---|---|---|
| City transfer tax (seller) | 1.5% | 1% up to $500,000, 1.425% above (one to three families); 1.425% up to $500,000, 2.625% above (four families) |
| State transfer tax (seller) | 0.4% | 0.4% |
| Where the records live | Westchester County Clerk; City of Yonkers for permits and certificates of occupancy | NYC ACRIS for deeds and mortgages; NYC Department of Buildings for certificates of occupancy |
The transfer tax difference between a three-family and a four-family building in the Bronx is large. On a $900,000 sale, the NYC tax is $12,825 for a three-family at 1.425% and $23,625 for a four-family at 2.625%. Ask me to confirm which category your building falls in before you set a price.
In Yonkers, the city transfer tax of 1.5% and the state's 0.4% come to 1.9%, or $16,616 at October's $874,500 median.
The rent roll is your most important document
Investors and owner-occupant buyers both start with the rent roll. A clean one lists, for every unit:
- Unit number, bedroom count and approximate size
- Current monthly rent and what the rent includes (heat, hot water, electric)
- Lease start and end dates, or month-to-month status
- Security deposit held
- Any rent-regulated status, if it applies to the building
Back it up with copies of the leases and 12 months of bank deposits or statements. Documented income is valued; income a buyer cannot verify gets discounted. The same goes for expenses: real tax, water, insurance and repair figures support your price better than estimates.
How buyers finance a multi-family home
Financing shapes who can buy your building and how fast.
Owner-occupant buyers can often use residential mortgages for two- to four-family homes, including some low down payment programs, because they will live in the building. Many lenders count part of the expected rent from the other units toward the buyer's income, which is one more reason documented leases matter.
Investors usually need a larger down payment, and their lender looks closely at the building's income and expenses.
Appraisals for two- to four-family homes include a rent schedule, so the appraiser compares your rents with market rents in the area. Rents well below market lower the income value; rents a lender cannot verify may be left out.
Lender rules change and vary by buyer. I ask every buyer's agent for a preapproval or proof of funds and the loan type before I recommend an offer.
Before you list: a short checklist
- Confirm the legal unit count. Pull the certificate of occupancy from the City of Yonkers or the NYC Department of Buildings. If the building is used differently from what the certificate says, buyers and lenders will find out, so find out first.
- Assemble the rent roll and leases. Include security deposits and how they are held.
- Gather 12 months of expenses. Property tax, water and sewer, insurance, fuel, repairs and service contracts.
- Check open permits and violations. Open items can delay a closing or force a price change late in the deal.
- Decide how the units will be delivered. Vacant, occupied or a mix affects both buyer pools differently. Lease and occupancy questions are legal matters, so review them with your attorney.
- Run your net. Use the net proceeds calculator, and see every cost in my seller closing costs guide.
Get a written valuation for your building
An online estimate cannot see your rents, leases, expenses or the condition of each unit, and that is where most of a multi-family home's value sits. I invest in real estate myself, and I read a rent roll the way your buyers will. With your documents in hand, I will prepare a written valuation that combines nearby multi-family sales with a full income analysis, plus a net sheet with your transfer taxes.
Call or text me at 914-430-0440, request a free home value estimate, or read more about the city in my Yonkers neighborhood guide. I work in English and Spanish.
Sources: OneKey MLS closed sales, October 2026, compiled by Rafael Barbosa. NYC Department of Finance, Real Property Transfer Tax; NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, real estate transfer tax; City of Yonkers, Real Estate Transfer Tax. Small samples change from month to month. This article is general information and not legal, tax or lending advice; consult your attorney or CPA.
Frequently asked questions
What do multi-family homes sell for in Yonkers?
In October 2026, ten two- to four-family homes closed in Yonkers at a median of $874,500, with a median of 42 days on the market, based on OneKey MLS closed sales compiled by Rafael Barbosa. It was the highest median of any property type in Yonkers that month.
How is a two- or three-family house valued?
Buyers compare recent sales of similar multi-family homes nearby and also value the income the building produces after a vacancy allowance and operating expenses. A sound asking price holds up under both methods.
What documents do I need to sell a multi-family home?
A current rent roll, copies of all leases, a list of security deposits, the last 12 months of property tax, water and sewer bills, your insurance declaration page, any service contracts and the certificate of occupancy showing the legal unit count.
What are the transfer taxes on a multi-family sale in Yonkers and the Bronx?
In Yonkers the seller pays 1.5% to the city plus 0.4% to New York State, 1.9% in total. In the Bronx, a two- or three-family home pays the NYC transfer tax of 1% up to $500,000 or 1.425% above, plus 0.4% to the state. A four-family building falls in a higher NYC rate category of 1.425% up to $500,000 and 2.625% above.
Can buyers use rental income to qualify for a mortgage on a two-family home?
Often yes. Many lenders count part of the expected rent from the other unit when an owner-occupant buyer applies, which is why documented leases and rents matter. Each lender sets its own rules.

